Documented Changesindependent research archive
← Back to catalog
MUD-2022-0022022

John 5:28, 29: basis of resurrection of life and judgment

The judgment during the Millennium remains relevant in both explanations; what has changed is the period to which the actions of John 5:29 refer.

interpretative reviewhigh

The documentary point

What's changed

The comparison of publications indicates the passage from the previous formulation to the later one below. The description preserves the limitations recorded by the sources themselves.

PREVIOUS UNDERSTANDING

Previous position

Doing good or bad things was applied to behavior after the resurrection. Resurrection of life or judgment would be the result achieved after the probation period.

LATER UNDERSTANDING

Later position

In 2022, the actions were applied to what people did before death. Righteous receive resurrection of life and unrighteous resurrection of judgment, though future reaction still determines the permanent outcome.

Chronology

Documented sequence

  1. Previous position

    Doing good or bad things was applied to behavior after the resurrection. Resurrection of life or judgment would be the result achieved after the probation period.

    PUBLICATION OF THE PREVIOUS POSITION
    “So, at John 5:28, 29a , Jesus was pointing ahead to the resurrection; then, in the remainder of verse 29 , he was expressing the outcome after they had been uplifted to human perfection and been put on judgment.”
    Scriptural Reasoning, “Resurrection” sectionOpen official source ↗
  2. Review and implementation

    In 2022, the actions were applied to what people did before death. Righteous receive resurrection of life and unrighteous resurrection of judgment, though future reaction still determines the permanent outcome.

    PUBLICATION OF THE CHANGE OR LATER POSITION
    “d In contrast, the terms “the righteous” and “the unrighteous” found at Acts 24:15 and the words “those who did good things” and “those who practiced vile things” found at John 5:29 focus on the conduct of the resurrected ones before they died.”
    The Watchtower, September 2022, paras 1–3 and note dOpen official source ↗
  3. Limits and evidence status

    The change was used as a basis for further adjustments in 2024.

    high

Editorial note

The change was used as a basis for further adjustments in 2024.

Classification: interpretative review. Category: Resurrection and judgment. Documentary strength: High.

When the original publication is not available in the official collection consulted, the page explicitly identifies the later source as retrospective. The citations are short and should be read in context by the links above.