Identity and destiny of the great crowd
The central change was not the creation of earthly hope itself. Before 1935 there were already explanations about people who would live on Earth. The adjustment specifically identified the great crowd of Revelation 7 with the other sheep of earthly hope.
The documentary point
What's changed
The comparison of publications indicates the passage from the previous formulation to the later one below. The description preserves the limitations recorded by the sources themselves.
Previous position
The great crowd was understood as a secondary heavenly class. Its members would be Christians with some zeal, but considered less faithful than the 144,000 and, therefore, would not reign with Christ.
Later position
On May 31, 1935, a speech at the Washington Convention identified the great crowd with the other sheep. The new class was situated on Earth, with prospects of surviving the great tribulation. The content was published in English in August 1935.
Chronology
Documented sequence
- Previous position
The great crowd was understood as a secondary heavenly class. Its members would be Christians with some zeal, but considered less faithful than the 144,000 and, therefore, would not reign with Christ.
PUBLICATION OF THE PREVIOUS POSITION“The Bible Students thought that the great crowd must be made up of Christians who had not been fully obedient to God while on earth.”
The Watchtower, September 2019, paras 6–7 — official retrospectiveOpen official source ↗ - Review and implementation
On May 31, 1935, a speech at the Washington Convention identified the great crowd with the other sheep. The new class was situated on Earth, with prospects of surviving the great tribulation. The content was published in English in August 1935.
PUBLICATION OF THE CHANGE OR LATER POSITION“These are being baptized in symbol, thus testifying that they . . . have taken their stand on the side of Jehovah and serve him and his King.”
Proclaimers of the Kingdom of God, chap. 12 — official historical reconstructionOpen official source ↗ - Limits and evidence status
The original editions of 1886 and 1935 are not available in Portuguese in the consulted collection; the citations come from official retrospectives.
high; documentary chain in medium-high Portuguese
Editorial note
The original editions of 1886 and 1935 are not available in Portuguese in the consulted collection; the citations come from official retrospectives.
Classification: historical line of doctrinal review. Category: religious identity heavenly/terrestrial hope and eschatology. Documentary strength: high; documentary chain in medium-high portuguese.
When the original publication is not available in the official collection consulted, the page explicitly identifies the later source as retrospective. The citations are short and should be read in context by the links above.