Religious institutions, schools, boarding schools, orphanages, care agencies, sports organizations, youth groups, public agencies and other institutions in which children suffered or could have suffered sexual abuse.
“ There is no evidence before the Royal Commission that the organisation has communicated any of these allegations to the police or other secular authority.”
Geographic dossier audited · 2015-2021
Australia: Royal Commission, Watchtower and Geoffrey Jackson
A documentary reading of the hearings, internal archives, public conclusions, institutional defense, the testimony of a member of the Governing Body and the review carried out in 2017.
Before you joined the case
What was the Royal Australian Commission?
A Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse was a public research commission established in Australia in 2013. It was not specifically designed to investigate Jehovah’s Witnesses. His mandate covered public and private institutions of different types.
As these institutions prevented abuse, they received complaints, protected children, investigated accusations, communicated authorities, administered risks, supported survivors and offered reparation.
The Commission could convene witnesses, demand documents, hold public hearings and private sessions, forward information to the police and produce conclusions and recommendations.
Nope. She examined institutional responses and produced findings based on the civil evidence pattern. It did not replace police, prosecutor or courts and did not automatically declare the criminal guilt of each person mentioned.
What the Commission has investigated — and what the figures do not prove
Case Study 29 examined how Jehovah’s Witnesses and Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of Australia Ltd received, investigated, and administered allegations of child sexual abuse. The hearings took place between July 27 and August 14, 2015; the report was released on November 28, 2016.
The files covered allegations, reports, complaints, confessions and different internal or criminal results. So, 1,006 people accused does not mean 1,006 convictions. The 579 confessional records also do not automatically equate to formalized criminal confessions before police or court.
Public findings
Policies and practices considered problematic
The organization declared compliance with mandatory communication laws and did not prevent personal complaints. However, the Commission did not find general practice of institutional referral when the law did not oblige.
In the absence of confession, internal discipline depended on Scriptural standards of proof. The Commission found the inflexible application of this rule to child sexual abuse to be wrong.
At least until 1998, whistleblowers might have to file charges in the presence of the accused. Representatives said that this was no longer required in 2015.
Only men investigated and judged. The Commission considered that this structure could worsen the suffering of girls and women.
There was no clear and uniform written prediction of a companion chosen by the survivor at all stages of the internal procedure.
The Commission considered that the precautionary measures against recurrence were limited and considered that social leave could place survivors who wanted to leave in an unsustainable position.
14 August 2015
Geoffrey Jackson's testimony
Geoffrey William Jackson, a member of the Governing Body since 2005, has testified under oath. He explained the group’s authority, its participation in committees, and the role of the Governing Body in Bible interpretation and policy approval.
“[The Governing Body is] a spiritual group of men who are the guardians of our doctrine.”
“ I think it would seem rather presumptuous to say that we are the only spokesman God is using.”
The report did not sum up the second sentence as simple denial. He stated that Jackson's response seemed incompatible. with documents according to which members considered the Governing Body the “channel” by which Jehovah’s will was communicated to them.
Internal test pattern
The rule of the two witnesses
The report recorded that an allegation could be established internally by confession by two or three witnesses considered credible by witnesses of similar incidents or by strong circumstantial evidence witnessed by at least two persons.
“The Royal Commission considers the application of the rule of the two witnesses in cases involving child sexual abuse to be wrong.”
Jackson recognized during the hearing possible role for circumstantial evidence. In a further statement, however, he maintained that Deuteronomy 22:25–27 was no exception to the Scriptural requirement of two witnesses to establish guilt.
Cases examined
BCG and BCB
He reported abuse by his father, then a ministerial servant. You had to bring the charge before him. The father later confessed in the congregational process, was disfellowshipped and then reinstated. Years later, BCG went to the police; after three trials, he was convicted.
He reported abuse for an elder. Without second witness and without confession, the elders considered internal proof insufficient. The accused stopped serving as an elder. The Commission found no evidence of institutional referral to the police.
The codes preserve the identity of the survivors. Their cases demonstrate how certain policies worked, but they should not be automatically generalized to every congregation or country.
Organisation position
The defense presented by Watchtower Australia
- Intrafamily abuse would not automatically become institutional because elders did spiritual research.
- Religion does not operate schools, daycare, orphanages, or youth groups that remove children from the care of their parents.
- Primary responsibility for protection would lie with parents.
- The organization claimed to abhor abuse, comply with mandatory communication and recognize the right to seek out police.
- The congregational process would be spiritual and distinct from criminal investigation.
- The rule of the two witnesses would have Scriptural basis.
Institutional review
2017: changes and issues that remained
Case Study 54 examined the response to the previous report. The organization described letters, training, and clarifications: the victim would not need to confront the accused; he would have the right to seek out the authorities; and elders would receive updated guidance.
The discussion continued:
- the rule of the two witnesses;
- the lack of policy to spontaneously communicate all cases beyond legal obligation;
- the communication of changes mainly to the elders;
- support for young survivors;
- the absence of women as decision makers;
- ostracism;
- the repair.
In 2021, Jehovah’s Witnesses joined the National Redress Scheme. Adherence allowed processing requests for repair, but did not retrospectively change the 2016 findings.
Submitted video
How to use the YouTube record
Royal Commission of Australia and the Governing Body on Pedophilia, 2015
The video of approximately three hours reproduces extensive part of the testimony. It's useful to hear the hearing, but it was published by third party in 2021. Title, description, editing and subtitles are not official documents.
Editorial rule: all citations should be checked in the transcript of Day 155. The video is an auxiliary record, not a substitute for the government source.
Open videoPrimary sources
Conference documents
Documentary limits
Accusation is not conviction; internal confession is not criminal sentence; submission of part is not found by the Commission; religious procedure does not replace police investigation; and third party video does not replace official transcription.